Date: 08 Oct 2014 9:03 PM Title: Chapter 1
Totally logical and loving at the same time. You did a very good job of presenting all facets of this situation, telling a wonderful tale at the same time!
[Report This]Date: 06 Dec 2013 5:28 PM Title: Chapter 1
i think that this was a brilliant interpretation of how carlisle would've been
Date: 02 Jun 2012 1:33 AM Title: Chapter 1
This was neat! Thanks for writing!
[Report This]Date: 10 Apr 2011 3:49 PM Title: Chapter 1
Another brilliant story from you. I really liked how you described Carlisle's doubts, and questions about his role in this whole situation. Amazing writing yet again.
[Report This]Date: 10 Nov 2010 4:45 AM Title: Chapter 1
This was an excellent story from Carlisle & Esme's perspective.
Date: 18 Oct 2010 4:07 AM Title: Chapter 1
I totally loved this POV - it is as I imagined Carlisle's POV to be. I frankly, hated all the Jake in the last three books.
[Report This]Date: 17 Oct 2010 9:09 PM Title: Chapter 1
Thank you thank you thank you. This was a POV that I have waited a long time to see written of that scene. You did an excellent job of protraying what I believe Carlisle was feeling. I hope that you keep writing.
Author's Response:
Thank you so much for you enthusiastic review! The scope of this was huge, so putting it in a o/s was challenging, but I so love Carlisle, I couldn't resist giving it a try.
I appreciate you taking the time to review -- and I'm a HP fan too!
[Report This]Date: 17 Oct 2010 4:48 AM Title: Chapter 1
I thought this was really well written and I enjoyed reading it. I'm sure it was quite a challenge, but you did a fantastic job, especially in keeping everyone "in character" and canon. Thanks for writing this and sharing it with us.
Author's Response:
Thank you for the complimentary review! The more I thought about it, the more I realized how conflicted Carlilse prob. really was -- a man of faith, and a man of science -- and a father to Bella and Edward. Sheez! I almost wonder if he was glad Esme took the decision from him!